The Teleology of the Modern Nation-State
Japan and China
Encounters with Asia
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press, Inc.
256 pages, 152.00 x 229.00 x 0.00 mm, 6 illus.
- ISBN: 9780812238204
- Published: October 2004
Japan and China did not begin to emerge as unified political entities until the nineteenth century. Yet scholars and politicians persistently refer to "Japan" and "China" in discussions of earlier periods, as if the modern nation-state had long been established in these regions. Joshua Fogel here brings together essays by eight renowned East Asian scholars to demonstrate why this oversight distorts our historical analysis and understanding of both countries. The nation-states of Japan and China developed much later and, indeed, far less uniformly than usually conveyed in popular myth and political culture. Moreover, the false depiction of an earlier national identity not only alters the factual record; it serves the contemporary engines of nationalist mythology and propaganda.
This interdisciplinary volume asks deceptively simple questions: When did "Japan" and "China" become Japan and China? When and why do inhabitants begin to define their identity and interests nationally rather than locally? Identifying the role of mitigating factors from disease and travel abroad to the subtleties of political language and aesthetic sensibility, the answers provided in these diverse and insightful essays are appropriately complex. By setting aside Western notions of the nation-state, the contributors approach each region on its own terms, while the thematic organization of the book provides a unique lens through which to view the challenges common to understanding both Japan and China. This highly readable collection will be important to scholars both inside and beyond the field of East Asian studies.
Introduction: The Teleology of the Nation-State
PART ONE. THE EMERGENCE OF A "JAPAN" AND A "CHINA"
1. The Emergence of Aesthetic Japan: Art Networks and Popular Publishing in the Formation of Proto-Modern Identity
2. The North(west)ern Peoples and the Recurrent Origins of the "Chinese" State
PART TWO. BRINGING THE STATE IN
3. State-Making in Global Context: Japan in a World of Nation-States
4. When Did China Become China? Thoughts on the Twentieth Century
—William C. Kirby
PART THREE. NATION AND NATIONALITY
5. Civilization and Enlightenment: Markers of Identity in Nineteenth-Century Japan
—David L. Howell
6. Nationality and Difference in China: The Post-Imperial Dilemma
—Pamela Kyle Crossley
PART FOUR. LOCALE, NATION, EMPIRE
7. Cultivating Nonnational Historical Understandings in Local History
—Luke S. Roberts
8. Where Do Incorrect Political Ideas Come From? Writing the History of the Qing Empire and the Chinese Nation
—Peter C. Perdue
"A rich and challenging book."—JAH