Selected by Choice magazine as an Outstanding Academic Title
Between 1990 and 1996, the U.S. Congress passed market-based reforms in the areas of civil rights, welfare, and immigration in a series of major legislative initiatives. These were announced as curbs on excessive rights and as correctives to a culture of dependency among the urban poor—stock images of racial and cultural minorities that circulated well beyond Congress. But those images did not circulate unchallenged, even after congressional opposition failed. In The Paradox of Relevance, Carol J. Greenhouse provides a political and literary history of the anthropology of U.S. cities in the 1990s, where—below the radar—New Deal liberalism, with its iconic bond between society and security, continued to thrive. The Paradox of Relevance opens in the midst of anthropology's so-called postmodern crisis and the appeal to relevance as a basis for reconciliation and renewal. The search for relevance leads outward to the major federal legislation of the 1990s and the galvanic political tensions between rights- and market-based reforms. Anthropologists' efforts to inform those debates through "relevant" ethnography were highly patterned, revealing the imprint of political tensions in shaping their works' central questions and themes, as well as their organization, narrative techniques, and descriptive practices. In that sense, federal discourse dominates the works' demonstrations of ethnography's relevance; however, the authors simultaneously resist that dominance through innovations in their own literariness—in particular, drawing on diasporic fiction and sociolegal studies where these articulate more agentive meanings of identity and difference. The paradox of relevance emerges with the realization that in the context of the times, affirming the relevance of ethnography as value-neutral science required the textual practices of advocacy and art.
1. Relevance in Question
2. Templates of Relevance
3. Texts and Contexts
4. Textual Strategy and the Politics of Form
5. The Discourse of Solutions
6. Democracy in the First Person
7. Gendering Difference and the Impulse to Fiction
8. Markets for Citizenship
Envoi: Empirical Citizenship
Carol J. Greenhouse is the Arthur W. Marks '19 Professor of Anthropology Emeritus at Princeton University. She is author and editor of numerous books, including Ethnographies of Neoliberalism and The Paradox of Relevance: Ethnography and Citizenship in the United States, both available from the University of Pennsylvania Press.
Christina L. Davis is Professor in the Department of Government at Harvard University and the Susan S. and Kenneth L. Wallach Professor at the Radcliffe Institute. She is author of Why Adjudicate? Enforcing Trade Rules in the WTO and Food Fights Over Free Trade: How International Institutions Promote Agricultural Trade Liberalization.