Augustine and the Limits of Politics
Catholic Ideas for a Secular World
Published by: University of Notre Dame Press
174 pages, 140.00 x 216.00 x 10.00 mm
- ISBN: 9780268020019
- Published: April 2018
Now with a new foreword by Patrick J. Deneen.
Jean Bethke Elshtain brings Augustine's thought into the contemporary political arena and presents an Augustine who created a complex moral map that offers space for loyalty, love, and care, as well as a chastened form of civic virtue. The result is a controversial book about one of the world's greatest and most complex thinkers whose thought continues to haunt all of Western political philosophy. What is our business "within this common mortal life?" Augustine asks and bids us to ask ourselves. What can Augustine possibly have to say about the conditions that characterize our contemporary society and appear to put democracy in crisis? Who is Augustine for us now and what do his words have to do with political theory? These are the underlying questions that animate Jean Bethke Elshtain's fascinating engagement with the thought and work of Augustine, the ancient thinker who gave no political theory per se and refused to offer up a positive utopia. In exploring the questions, Why Augustine, why now?
Elshtain argues that Augustine's great works display a canny and scrupulous attunement to the here and now and the very real limits therein. She discusses other aspects of Augustine's thought as well, including his insistence that no human city can be modeled on the heavenly city, and further elaborates on Hannah Arendt's deep indebtedness to Augustine's understanding of evil. Elshtain also presents Augustine's arguments against the pridefulness of philosophy, thereby linking him to later currents in modern thought, including Wittgenstein and Freud.
"[This] is a book that does much to rectify the kind of continuous injustice done Augustine by the modern secular world. People who have only a passing acquaintance with Augustine, and judge him mainly by prevailing attitudes, can learn much from Augustine and the Limits of Politics. . . . It is an intelligent, warm, and well-informed discussion." —American Political Science Review
“[Her] book is engagingly and charmingly written, and gently provokes the reader to take another look at Augustine.” —Dialogue
“Augustine provides us, as Elshtain puts it, ‘a complex moral map that offers space for loyalty and love and care, as well as for a chastened form of civic virtue’ (p. 91). This is not a guidebook to Utopia but a solid critical discipline for negotiating the affairs of the day.” — Academic Press
“Elshtain attains rare achievement of a work that is both creatively erudite, and streamlined. An almost ‘fat-free’ volume, Augustine and the Limits of Politics is inter-disciplinary enough to recommend itself to a broad range of people, from political philosophers, to historians of thought, to theologians.” —Journal of Religion and Culture
"This very engaging, very philosophical, and yet very personal book reintroduces Augustine to the heart of modern political philosophy. . . . All readers seriously interested in Augustine and responsive to him will welcome Elshtain's book as a refreshing breeze." —Theological Studies
“Augustine and the Limits of Politics should be required reading for undegraduates, graduates and scholars interested in Augustine, the current ‘identity’ debate, or the theory and ethics of war and peace.” —Journal of Religion and Culture
"Professor Elshtain has written an engaged, impassioned and highly personal book chronicling her own engagements with the writings of St. Augustine, and her own attempts to apply Augustine's political, social and ethical thought so as to make sense of present-day crises and anxieties." —International Studies in Philosophy
“Elstain’s hope is to reach those, especially among political philosophers and theologians, who have rejected Augustinian philosophy because of what has become the unjust but widespread tradition that he is a pessimist, a misogynist, a narcissist, and irrelevant to contemporary problems. With passion, Elshtain argues that the time is ripe for a reconsideration of Augustine’s Confessions and City of God.” —Review of Metaphysics